
Beyond Vermont By
C. M. Berman
Will Civil Unions spread to other states?
On July 1st, Vermont passed a historic
Civil Union Law that offers some of the benefits of marriage to
same-sex couples, and now at least seven other states are considering
similar laws.
Couples who receive a Vermont civil union have, for instance,
property and inheritance rights like those of married couples.
However, Vermont's Civil Unions are not currently recognized in
any other states or by the Federal Government. In fact, there
are thirty-two states that ban same-sex unions of any kind.
However, the Associated Press has reported that some states, many
of them in New England, are looking at the Vermont law as a possible
model for their own civil union bills. States where such bills
are being considered include Massachusetts, Rhode Island, New
Hampshire, Connecticut, New Jersey, and New York. According to
the Associated Press, David Smith of the Human Rights Campaign
said that "other legislatures wishing to enact equal benefits,
equal status for gay and lesbian people will look at this."
In New York, State Representative Tom Duane, a democrat from Manhattan,
has said that he is currently considering a bill based on the
Vermont Civil Union law. In Rhode Island, State Representative
Michael Pisurato is crafting legislation that would go further,
and expand marriage to include gays and lesbians.
Around the country, many still oppose any recognition of same-sex
couples. But the tremendous interest and discussion generated
by the passing of Vermont's bill has itself been valuable, according
to Tim Sweeney, the Deputy Executive Director of the Empire State
Pride Agenda in New York. "The whole movement in Vermont
has created a tremendous amount of education and discussion about
lesbian and gay relationships and the kind of discrimination we
face," said Sweeney. "It has been an extremely positive
discussion and very helpful to humanize lesbian and gay relationships
and our families."
To contact us by E-Mail
©2001 kp media group